If Law Enforcement Worked Like Health Care

February 2, 2012 § 3 Comments

The issue of health care has long been at the top of political debate and policy. Any Christian Democracy movement in the United States will be expected to have a sound, and comprehensive policy on health insurance and medical costs.  Medical costs continue to rise, insurance becomes less and less affordable, and the cost problem promises to get only worse as Baby Boomers enter their senior years.

Quality health care is just as essential to a prosperous and stable society as quality law enforcement, fire protection, education, infrastructure, as well as military to protect the population from invasion and rebellion.  Yet health care is the only one that hangs the shadow of debt and bankruptcy directly over families.

So what if law enforcement worked the same way as the health care system? A tongue-in-cheek short story may help express my thoughts:

Lena Svenson pulled out of her former employer’s parking lot, her eyes filled with tears. She had one cardboard box filled with her personal belongings and some files. Her company had downsized, and she had been laid off with over a dozen other employees. In addition to the lost income, she was equally concerned about the loss of her benefits, including her family’s cop insurance plan.  Her husband had lost his job last year, and was still looking for work.

Before heading home, Lena pulled in to her local branch office of Thin Blue Line/Blue Shield to discuss buying cop insurance for her family. She spoke to insurance agent Ole Olafson about her options.

“How many people are we covering with this policy?” asked Ole.

“Three,” replied Lena. “Myself, my husband, and our son.”

Ole looked over the forms and told Lena she would have to complete a pre-coverage “safety” screening by answering some safety related questions.

“Has your husband ever been violent towards you?”

“Yes, he hit me once years ago, but we’ve since been through counseling and are working together to repair our relationship,” said Lena.

“Oh, I’m sorry,” Ole replied, putting the forms back into a folder, “but domestic violence is a pre-existing condition, and we can’t cover you.”

Lena went home heartbroken, and broke the news of the job loss to her family. They decided the would have to risk not having cop insurance until one of them found a job.

Later that night, the police attempted to stop a man with a felony warrant in Lena’s neighborhood.  The man fled on foot, and took refuge in Lena’s home and took her family hostage.  Lena’s husband pleaded with the man to give himself up while Lena snuck away to use the phone and call 911.

Online with the dispatcher, Lena explained that the wanted man was in her house and holding her family. She demanded the police come and arrest him.

“What kind of insurance coverage do you have?” asked the dispatcher.

“None!” said Lena. “Please, save my family! Can’t the police storm the house and arrest him?”

“Well, ma’am,” replied the dispatcher, “we’re going to have to refer you to the SWAT Team, and since they’re a specialty practice, they’re all booked up until next month. They can help you, but without insurance you’re going to have to pay out-of-pocket, and right now hostage rescue runs about $24,000.”

No American would tolerate this, yet we tolerate it every day with health care.  I wish I had a solution to offer, but I do not. Families are suffering, public health is deteriorating, and Washington continues to play games with this issue.


§ 3 Responses to If Law Enforcement Worked Like Health Care

  • Exactly — the government must be involved in certain industries for the sake of the common good (http://www.dnu.org/service/commongood.pdf).

    I think that the recent Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act addresses many of these concerns. It has banned insurance providers from withholding a policy due to pre-existing conditions, and the individual mandate will help to bring health insurance costs down.

    But the law isn’t without its problems. It requires all employers of a certain size to provide health insurance that covers contraception, even including abortive pills. Churches are exempted, but not other religious institutions like schools and hospitals. As it violates the freedom of conscience of those (both the employers and the employees who must pay into the plan) who deem such practices immoral, I propose that the Christian democratic movement stand in opposition to this provision of the law. http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0212/72345.html

  • minnesotadan says:

    I agree. I have my doubts on the Constitutionality of the individual mandate, but I completely understand its necessity in order to cover the costs of removing denials based on pre-existing conditions and removing lifetime caps on coverages. I’m not against the mandate, I’m simply scratching my head at where Congress gets the power. At least the Supreme Court is anticipated to rule on that before the year is out. I’m much more concerned over the conscience issues you mentioned re: contraception and religious institutions.

    • Yeah, we’ll have to wait and let it play out in the courts. I don’t think we as a movement can take a stand on what is ultimately the Supreme Court’s decision. (Any objections to this statement?) If they decide it’s not Constitutional, then it’s back to the drawing board. Perhaps a Constitutional amendment is in order — or perhaps the matter should be left to the states.

      So I suppose we can mark opposition to the birth control mandate as a ***point of consensus*** for the time being. We invite anyone to speak up with any objections.

Please contribute your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading If Law Enforcement Worked Like Health Care at Christian Democracy and America's Future.


%d bloggers like this: